Martin Luther, the initiator of the Protestant Reformation, acknowledged that the term "Trinity" is not explicitly mentioned in the Holy Scriptures but rather was devised and fabricated by humans. The widely accepted belief is that the Trinity consists of God the Father, Jesus Christ the Son, and the Holy Spirit. The theology of the Trinity is commonly defined as the belief in the existence of one God who manifests in three separate yet equal individuals.
However, it is worth noting that the term "Trinity" did not gain widespread usage as a religious concept until several centuries after the final books of the Bible were finished, long after the departure of the apostles of Christ.
The New Bible Dictionary acknowledges that the term 'Trinity' is not explicitly mentioned in the Bible. Tertullian first employed this term at the end of the 2nd century, but it gained widespread usage and was formally explained only during the 4th and 5th centuries (1996, "Trinity").
The aforementioned source further elucidates that the formal theology of the Trinity emerged as a consequence of multiple insufficient endeavours to elucidate the true nature and identity of the Christian God. In order to address these issues, the Church Fathers convened in [A.D.] 325 at the Council of Nicaea with the purpose of establishing a precise and authentic biblical statement regarding the divine identity. However, it was not until the year 381, namely at the Council of Constantinople, that the affirmation of the divinity of the Spirit took place.
It is evident that the theology of the Trinity was not officially established until a considerable time after the completion of the Bible and the passing of the apostles. Later theologians required centuries to unravel their beliefs and articulate the concept of the Trinity.
What is the reason for theologians' inability to explain this doctrine?
Theologians' explanations of the doctrine of the Trinity are decidedly unclear. In his book "The Knowledge of the Holy," religious author A.W. Tozer asserts that the Trinity is an "incomprehensible enigma" and any efforts to understand it "will forever be fruitless." He acknowledges that churches, albeit not claiming to fully understand, have consistently imparted this idea (1961, pp. 17-18). He subsequently reaches the remarkable conclusion that the inability to provide a satisfactory explanation actually supports the argument, rather than weakening it (p. 23).
In his book "The Doctrine of the Trinity," Cyril Richardson, a professor of church history at Union Theological Seminary in New York, expressed the following statement while being a committed Trinitarian:
"In summary, my assessment of the doctrine of the Trinity is that it is a man-made concept..." The text generates perplexity instead of elucidation; and although it addresses genuine issues, its proposed solutions lack enlightenment. The assertions made by the author in 1958 have presented challenges for Christians due to their obscure and enigmatic nature. These statements lack clarity and precision in their choice of words, rendering them ultimately devoid of significance.
In addition, he acknowledged that the defence of the Trinity as a "revealed" doctrine is mostly an attempt to avoid addressing the issues that might be raised against it (p. 16).
The Dictionary of Religious Knowledge asserts that Trinitarians do not unanimously agree on the specific definition or explanation of the Trinity belief (Lyman Abbott, editor, 1885, "Trinitarians").
Why do even individuals who hold a belief in the Trinity encounter such challenges when attempting to explain it?
The explanation is straightforward yet startling: The Bible does not impart this knowledge. It is impossible to provide evidence or explain something from the Bible that is not in accordance with biblical teachings. The Bible is the sole dependable means through which divine revelation is conveyed to us. Indeed, it is evident that the notion of the Trinity is not included in God's divine disclosure to humanity.
Startling revelations on the absence of the Trinity in the Bible!
Let us take a look at statements made by several credible authorities and authors who, whilst confirming the concept of the Trinity, admit that the term "Trinity" and the corresponding theology are not explicitly mentioned in the Bible.
The International Standard Bible Encyclopaedia states that the term "trinity" originated in the second century and is not used in the Bible. Furthermore, the Scriptures do not provide a complete declaration on the concept of the trinity. The text asserts that the teaching was solidified by church fathers in the centuries that followed, much after the apostles had departed.
According to the HarperCollins Bible Dictionary, the New Testament does not include the formal theology of the Trinity as it was articulated by the significant church councils of the fourth and fifth century. The book "Trinity" was edited by Paul Achtemeier in 1996.
According to the HarperCollins Encyclopaedia of Catholicism, contemporary scholars generally concur that neither the Old Testament nor the New Testament has a specific theology of the Trinity. To assume that a Christian theory from the late fourth century or thirteenth century can be found in the Old Testament would greatly exceed its original meaning and concepts. Similarly, the New Testament does not explicitly present a teaching of the Trinity, as stated by Richard McBrien, the general editor in 1995 ("God," pp. 564-565).
The New Encyclopaedia Britannica states in its article on the Trinity that the term "Trinity" and the specific theology are absent from the New Testament. The philosophy evolved over an extended period of time spanning several centuries and was shaped by several conflicts.The concept of the three separate entities and their unity was not fully established until the 4th century, when a single orthodox theology was formulated, stating that there is one essence and three persons. This information is found in the 1985 edition of Micropaedia, Volume 11, page 928.
According to The New International Dictionary of New Testament Theology, early Christianity did not have a clear and specific concept of the Trinity like the ones that were later developed in the creeds of the early church (Colin Brown, editor, Vol. 2, 1976, "God," p. 84).
In his renowned book "The Outline of History," H.G. Wells, a historian and science fiction writer, highlights that there is no substantiated proof that the apostles of Jesus were ever acquainted with the concept of the trinity, particularly from Jesus himself (1920, Vol. 2, p. 499).
Martin Luther, the German priest who started the Protestant Reformation, acknowledged that the term 'Trinity' is not mentioned in the Holy Scriptures, but rather was created by humans, as stated in The Sermons of Martin Luther, edited by John Lenker, Vol. 3, 1988, p. 406.
In his esteemed publication "Basic Theology," Professor Charles Ryrie asserts that numerous concepts are embraced by evangelicals as being unequivocally conveyed in Scripture, despite the absence of explicit textual evidence. The doctrine of the Trinity is the most exemplary illustration of this. The Bible does not explicitly teach the doctrine of the Trinity. There is no evidence, in the form of a verse or chapter, that explicitly indicates the existence of one God who is composed of three persons.
According to Professor Erickson, the Trinity teaching did not originate from biblical philosophy, but rather emerged when biblical thought was influenced by Greek conceptions. According to the author, the theology of the Trinity not only exceeds but also distorts the biblical teachings about God.
According to Shirley Guthrie, Jr., a theology professor at Columbia Theological Seminary, the Bible does not convey the concept of the Trinity. The term 'trinity' and related phrases such as 'one-in-three,' 'three-in-one,' one 'essence' (or 'substance'), and three 'persons,' are not found in the Bible. The vocabulary employed in the doctrine is derived from classical Greek philosophy, as used in the ancient church (Christian Doctrine, 1994, pp. 76-77).
It is evident from these and other cited sources that the concept of a Trinity was not included in the writings of the Bible. However, it is widely acknowledged by numerous authorities that the idea of the Trinity underwent significant development much later, evolving over the course of several centuries.
In order to understand the circumstances that precipitated the emergence of this idea, it is necessary to delve into the profound and enigmatic patterns that originated in the initial decades of the early Church. This narrative is both startling and shocking in many ways.
Comments